S R Gym Surat S R Gym, Surat
WhatsApp Brijesh
Menu

Gym vs yoga, and why you can do both in the same hour

The short answer

You can do yoga and gym training together, and for most people that is the sensible answer rather than choosing one. Yoga gives you range of motion, breath control and balance, and weight training is the side of the pair that lets you keep adding load in small steps, which is the main driver of strength and muscle. At S R Gym the two happen in the same hour, because every session here opens with yoga and the twelve positions of Surya Namaskar before anybody touches a weight, and that has been the rule since 1999. If you can only pick one, pick the one you will still be doing in six months, since the practice you keep beats the better practice you abandon.

Brijesh Joshi, founder and head coach of S R Gym, Surat

Written by Brijesh Joshi

Founder of S R Gym, Surat, coaching since 1999. President of the Strength Bodybuilding Association South Gujarat and a registered IBBFF judge. See credentials.

Published
Reading time
8 min read

Almost everyone who asks me this question has already decided that one of the two has to be given up, usually because of time. I have coached in Surat since 1999 and I have never once told a member to choose, so what follows is the case for each of them stated fairly, the research stated with its limits attached, and then the arrangement we actually run here.

What each one genuinely gives you

Yoga deserves a fair hearing before any gym owner starts comparing it to his own product, so here is mine. A regular practice takes your joints to the end of their available range and keeps them able to go there, which is the first thing that disappears in a person who sits for ten hours a day. It trains balance and single-leg control, it teaches you to breathe deliberately, it costs nothing beyond a mat, and you can do it in a hotel room in a city you have never visited before. A great many members tell me it is the part of the hour that settles their head, and while that is their report rather than something I can measure, I hear it often enough to take it seriously.

Weight training gives you one thing that yoga has little mechanism for supplying, which is progressive load. You add a little weight or a repetition, your body adapts to it over the following days, and then you add a little more. That process is the main driver of strength and muscle and it is the kind of loading the skeleton responds to, and it also gives you a number that moves, which turns out to matter a great deal for keeping people coming back. The strength training page sets out how we programme it.

Put like that, the two are answering different questions about the same body, and the reason this comes up as a versus question at all is that studios sell one and gyms sell the other.

Yoga and gym, side by side

Each row is one thing people are actually trying to get, with what a yoga practice alone does for it, what gym training alone does for it, and what happens when the two sit in the same hour. Where the evidence is thin I have said so in the cell rather than in a footnote.

Yoga compared with gym training, and with both combined, across flexibility, strength, weight loss, back pain, stress, cost and time.
What you want Yoga on its own Gym training on its own Both in one session
Flexibility and range This is the strongest case yoga has. The clearest evidence sits in adults over 60, and the advantage over other active exercise is much smaller than the advantage over doing nothing. Lifting through a complete range is itself range work, and a deep squat done properly is both. Half repetitions give you very little. You open the range with the sequence, then load it. That is my coaching reasoning for the order rather than a trial result.
Strength and muscle Improves bodyweight holds, push-ups and sit-ups, mostly measured against people doing nothing in studies of ten or twenty people. There is very little scope to add load week after week. This is the whole point of it. Load goes up in small steps over months and the body adapts to what you keep asking of it. The weights do the strength work and the yoga keeps the range you are loading through available.
Weight loss Burns some energy and helps with adherence. I could find no proper head to head trial against gym training, so treat the calorie comparisons you read with caution. Holds on to muscle while you are eating less, which shapes a good deal of how you look at the end of it. Neither one outruns your kitchen. See weight loss coaching for how the food side is handled.
Long-standing back pain It is a reasonable first option and it is listed in clinical guidance. Starting appears to carry a small risk of temporary flare-up, roughly 43 people in 1,000 against 9 in 1,000 who did nothing, reported at low certainty. Back-focused exercise performs about as well as yoga on function, and builds tolerance for the loads daily life puts on you anyway. This is what we run here, alongside posture work. Red flag symptoms go to a doctor first.
Stress and how you sleep Widely reported by members, and the breathing work is the part they name. I pass that on as their experience rather than as a finding. Also widely reported, and an hour where nobody can reach you is worth something on its own. Members who do both tend to describe the opening sequence as the switch that ends the working day.
Equipment and cost A mat and a few square feet of floor, which is the honest advantage of it and the reason it travels so well. Needs a loaded floor and, in the first months, somebody watching what you do with it. Membership from ₹1,700 for one month with the yoga included, and the full fee page sets out the rest.
Time it takes 20 to 45 minutes for a practice worth the name, and it can be done at home before anyone else in the house is awake. 45 to 60 minutes, four or five days a week, plus the travel. One hour covering both, which is the arrangement most working members here settle on.

Doing both, and the order that works

A member arrives, and before touching a weight does the twelve positions of Surya Namaskar and a short mobility sequence. Four to six rounds, three or four minutes of it, and then the strength work starts. That has been the rule at both branches since the gym opened in 1999 and it applies to a nineteen-year-old wanting size and to a member in his sixties alike. The full sequence, drawn out position by position with the common errors, is on the Surya Namaskar guide, and the yoga and gym page covers what is included in a membership.

The ordering rule is simple to remember. Moving sequences go before the weights, where they raise body temperature and take the joints through their range while nothing is loaded. Long held stretches go at the end of the session or onto a rest day, because holding a deep stretch for a minute or more immediately before heavy lifting can leave you feeling less stable under the bar. One longer practice of 20 to 30 minutes on a rest day each week does more for your range than adding rounds to the warm-up ever will, and that last part is my coaching judgement from watching it play out here rather than a research finding.

The three kinds of place you could join

It helps to compare the categories rather than the signboards, so here are the three you will find in any Indian city. A dedicated yoga studio will teach you the practice properly, take you into pranayama and longer held asana, and give you a teacher whose whole training is in that tradition. A budget gym chain will sell you an inexpensive card and a floor full of equipment, and after the first week nobody will look at how you are moving. A coached gym costs more than the card and gives you somebody on the floor who watches, corrects and changes the programme as you go.

None of those three is the right answer for everyone, and I have sent people to the first one. If what you want is depth in the practice itself, a studio is better than any gym floor including mine. If you are experienced, warm yourself up without being told and simply need equipment near your house, the cheap card is a perfectly rational buy. Choosing a gym in Surat goes through the questions worth asking whichever of the three you walk into.

The verdict, goal by goal

Most people arrive with one goal rather than a general interest in fitness, so here is a straight answer for each of the common ones.

For flexibility, yoga leads

This is the clearest win yoga has, with the caveat that the good evidence sits in adults over 60 and the margin over other active exercise is modest. If you are 30 and stiff from sitting, my coaching read is that a good deal of the same benefit is available from lifting through a full range with somebody correcting you. Training after 40 covers the age group where this matters most.

For strength and muscle, the gym leads

I could find no trial putting yoga head to head against progressive weight training for strength, so nobody can honestly hand you a number here. What the mechanism suggests is that muscle and strength come largely from adding load over time, and yoga gives you very little scope to add load. That is a reason to do both rather than a reason to dismiss yoga, and one large review of yoga in older adults did find improved lower limb strength against inactive controls, with a smaller and less certain advantage over people doing other active exercise.

For weight loss, the kitchen leads and training supports it

Neither one has beaten the other in any trial I have been able to find. Weight training earns its place by holding on to muscle while you eat less, and yoga earns its place by being the thing many members will actually keep doing. Most of the calories-burned-per-session figures quoted for the two cite nothing at all, so I would treat them carefully.

For long-standing back pain, they are close

The reviews put yoga and other back-focused exercise at about the same level for function, which is set out with its limits in the next section. The practical answer I give in the gym is to do both, since the mobility work restores range that sitting has taken away and the strength work builds tolerance for load.

For a complete beginner, start with whichever you will keep

Adherence beats optimisation by a wide margin in my experience of watching people start here since 1999. A yoga practice you do five mornings a week is worth more than a gym membership you visit twice a month, and the reverse is equally true. The first 90 days guide is written around exactly that problem.

What the evidence actually says

I would rather you arrived with accurate expectations than impressive ones, so here is the research with its limits attached. Where a claim is my coaching judgement rather than a finding, I have said so in the same sentence.

Back pain

The Cochrane review of yoga for chronic non-specific low back pain, updated in 2022, compared yoga against other back-focused exercise and found probably little or no difference in back-specific function, at moderate certainty. For pain itself the same review rates the evidence very low certainty and says it remains uncertain whether there is any difference at all, which is a weaker statement than the one usually repeated online. Against doing no exercise, yoga produced improvements that were statistically real and smaller than the reviewers' own threshold for a change a patient would call meaningful, and it carried a small increase in temporary flare-ups of existing back pain, roughly 43 people in 1,000 against 9 in 1,000, at low certainty.

Clinical guidance

The American College of Physicians guideline of 2017 lists 13 non-drug options to try before medication for long-standing back pain, and yoga is one of them. The guideline does not rank the 13 against each other, and the evidence behind the yoga entry specifically was graded low quality, so being on that list is a fair endorsement of yoga as one reasonable option among several.

Flexibility

The largest meta-analysis of yoga in older adults, published in the International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity in 2019, found a moderate improvement in lower body flexibility against inactive controls and roughly half that advantage against people doing other active exercise such as walking. The average participant was over 60 with no particular condition, so I would not carry that number across to a 28-year-old and neither should anyone selling you a class.

Strength

I could find no trial putting yoga head to head against progressive resistance training for strength or muscle size, so nobody can give you a number. What the yoga trials show is improvement in push-ups, sit-ups and bodyweight holds, measured mostly against people doing nothing, in studies of 10 or 20 participants. One 2013 trial of eight weeks of yoga in young adults improved isometric strength and flexibility while grip strength and aerobic fitness did not change at all.

Weight loss

I could find no head to head trial of yoga against gym training for weight loss in a general population, which is itself the finding. The full reference list for the sources above, including the energy cost of Surya Namaskar measured in an Indian study, sits on the Surya Namaskar guide rather than being repeated here.

Yoga or gym: the importance of both

Seven minutes in Hindi, recorded in 2020, on why these two belong in the same session.

Watch on YouTube

The same answer, said out loud

I recorded this before the website existed, and the position has not moved since. If you would rather hear it than read it, this is the short version in Hindi, and there are more recordings on the guides page.

Who this is for, and who it is not for

Doing both in one hour suits some people very well and suits others badly, and I would rather set out both halves than only the flattering one.

Who this is for

  • You have been going back and forth between the two for months and what you actually need is somebody to tell you that both is allowed.
  • You sit for nine or ten hours a day, arrive stiff, and have about one hour to give this. Training around a working day covers the scheduling side.
  • You are past 40 and want to keep your range and your balance while you build strength, which is where the two goals meet most usefully.
  • You have a long-standing ache in the back or neck that a doctor has already looked at, and you want mobility work somebody watches you do.
  • You are a woman starting out and would rather learn in a place where the reasoning is explained as you go. What training here is like.

Who this is not for

  • You want a timetabled group yoga class at a fixed hour with a place booked and a teacher at the front of the room. There is no such class here and a studio will serve you far better.
  • You want to go deeper into the practice itself, into pranayama and long held asana. A warm-up sequence will never be a substitute for proper study of it.
  • Your back pain travels down a leg, or arrives with numbness, weakness or any change in bladder or bowel control. A doctor comes before any gym floor, mine included.
  • You are experienced, warm yourself up without being told, and simply want equipment and a quiet hour near your house. An ordinary card at whichever gym is nearest will do that job for less money.
  • Sunday is the only day you could come, because both branches close on Sunday and that is not going to change.
  • You are looking for supplements or for somebody to guide you through anabolic steroid use, since we sell no supplements at all and I will not coach steroid use at any level. My position on that.

Where, when and what it costs

Membership starts at ₹1,700 for one month, and the yoga is part of it rather than an add-on you decline at the counter. Personal training, where the whole hour is programmed and supervised, starts at ₹7,000 for one month. Katargam opens at 5am and Adajan at 6am, both until 10pm, Monday to Saturday, and both close on Sunday. How personal training runs.

Yoga or gym: the questions people ask me

Can I do yoga and gym on the same day?
Yes, and the same session is better still. A moving sequence such as Surya Namaskar takes three or four minutes and prepares the joints for loading, so it belongs at the start of the training hour rather than on a separate day. If you would rather keep them apart, do the gym session in the morning and a longer yoga practice in the evening, or put the longer practice on a rest day. The only pairing I would avoid is a long session of deep held stretches immediately before heavy lifting, because holding a stretch for a minute or more can leave you feeling less stable under the bar for a while afterwards.
What should I do first, yoga or gym?
Yoga first when it is a moving sequence, and weights after. Surya Namaskar at a moderate pace raises body temperature and takes the major joints through their range while nothing is loaded, which is what you want in the ten minutes before a squat. Long held stretches are better placed at the end of the session or on a rest day. That order is the house rule at both branches and the reasoning is set out in full on our Surya Namaskar guide.
Is yoga enough exercise on its own?
For somebody currently doing nothing, yoga alone is a real improvement, and most people I have taught notice a change in how they move within a few weeks. For flexibility, balance and a calmer half hour it is genuinely good. For building strength and muscle it runs out of road sooner, because yoga gives you very little scope to add load week after week, and adding load over time is the mechanism most of the evidence points to for building both. The honest position is that yoga is enough to be worth doing on its own, and limited on its own if strength is what you are after.
Which is better for weight loss, yoga or gym?
Neither one wins on the strength of the evidence, because I have not been able to find a good head to head trial of yoga against gym training for weight loss to point at. Weight loss comes from eating less than you spend over a long stretch of months, and the training you choose mainly decides how much muscle you keep while that happens and how likely you are to keep turning up. My coaching judgement, from running this gym since 1999, is that weight training plus walking holds on to more muscle than yoga alone does, and that the yoga is what keeps a lot of members turning up at all. Be careful with the calorie per session figures you see quoted online, since almost none of them cite anything.
I have back pain. Is yoga or the gym better for it?
For long-standing, non-specific back pain the evidence does not clearly favour either. The Cochrane review of yoga for chronic low back pain, updated in 2022, found probably little or no difference between yoga and other back-focused exercise in back-specific function, at moderate certainty, and for pain itself the same review calls the evidence very low certainty and says it remains uncertain whether there is any difference at all. The American College of Physicians guideline of 2017 lists yoga among thirteen non-drug options to try first, and grades the evidence behind the yoga entry as low quality. If your pain travels down a leg, or comes with numbness, weakness or any change in bladder or bowel control, see a doctor before you start anything.
Is yoga or gym better for women starting out?
The same answer applies to women as to men, which is that both together beat either alone, and the reason has nothing to do with sex. Loading the skeleton matters for bone density as the years go on, and lifting something progressively heavier is the most direct way I know of loading it. What does differ in practice is how a first month feels on a gym floor, so at both branches somebody is on the floor explaining each movement while you learn it, and the yoga at the start of the session gives most newcomers something familiar to begin with.

I write here as a coach who has completed a foundation course in yoga science, not as a yoga teacher, so treat this page as general information rather than as medical advice. If you have back pain that travels down a leg, numbness, weakness, unexplained weight loss, fever, or any change in bladder or bowel control, see a doctor rather than beginning an exercise routine on your own.

Still deciding something else

Most people arrive with more than one of these unresolved. The other three are written the same way, which is to say the answer is sometimes no.

Come and do one session of both

One hour on the floor will settle this question faster than any comparison table can. Call +91 98790 69960, or send a message and say which branch is closer to you.

Message on WhatsApp